Equity Leadership: Impact on Employee Engagement

Shortly after their publication in a major research journal, two social science researchers from Concordia University Wisconsin and Ann Arbor were invited to present a new leadership model and their research findings on the world stage in Dublin, Ireland. Furthermore, the research team has been asked to present their leadership model to HR leaders at the 2023 WI-SHRM Conference, confirming that our professors and doctoral programs are making a difference in the world and impacting organizational development.

Concordia’s School of Business Dean, Dr. Matthew Hurtienne, and Dr. Laura Hurtienne, Assistant Professor of Business and Director for CUWAA’s Doctor of Business Administration, conceptualized gaps within current leadership models. Through previously conducted studies, the research team saw themes regarding the importance of individual employee attention. A recent study showed that their model is a predictor for improving employee engagement that can lead to increased productivity and employee retention.

What is Equity Leadership

Strolling through the leadership section of a bookstore or browsing through Amazon’s leadership books, you’ll soon realize there’s an abundance of theories and suggestions on successful leadership. Many of these books tend to categorize employees as if they cut them from the same dough, making them identical. However, isn’t it accurate to say that each employee is unique, with their own needs and personal motivations?

In recent years, organizations have started to recognize that each employee has a unique background, different cultural norms, and even various aspirations. To provide adequate support for the diverse realm of personalities means diverging from many leadership practices of the past.   

Equity leadership (EL) “identifies individual employee’s personal and professional resources, relationships, and opportunity needs in an effort to support and encourage employees to reach their fullest potential in the workforce and increase positive organizational outcomes” (Hurtienne & Hurtienne, 2023). This theory, recently developed and published in a top-tier research journal, acknowledges that leaders need to take the time to understand each employee as a separate individual in an effort to motivate each one, leading to increased productivity, employee retention, and employee engagement (Hurtienne & Hurtienne, 2023).

Direct leaders can engage in conversations with followers that provide insight regarding how to support each individual through intentional, consistent one-on-one meetings with employees. Building trust between leaders and their subordinates is important for positive outcomes in an organization’s structure.

Connections to employee engagement

Employee engagement is the amount in which employees are willing to invest in the success of the organization (Hurtienne & Hurtienne, 2020). We know that employee engagement leads to high levels of the triple P’s: passion, productivity, and performance. Additionally, leaders need to recognize that they can’t force employees to be more engaged; the direct actions of the leader engage employees.

Consider employee engagement as a process that requires continuous nurturing and ongoing constructive actions with each employee. To commit to this view, see engagement strategies through the lens of each employee.

Organizational leaders and human resource offices should continuously look for ways to unleash human expertise and potential (Swanson and Holtan, 2009). Based on their own personal experiences and connections to the organization, individual employees will decide whether to be engaged or not. Leaders can affect employee performance through distinctive interactions and employment decisions. Positive perceptions of these interactions can lead to higher levels of employee engagement and the successful development of individual employees.

This means that there is a positive correlation between leaders meeting employees where they are. The concept of equity leadership provides the chance for leaders to better understand their employees on a more personal level, leading to the growth of each individual.

Connection of Equity Leadership to the Bible

Concordia University grounds our education in the Christian Faith and the one Triune God. Faculty research and curricula weave the works of the Bible and the Christian faith into them. The concept of equity is not a new concept; the Bible tells us that everyone is made in God’s image (Genesis 1:27), and although we are one in Jesus Christ (Galatians 3:28), each person has different abilities (Matthew 25:15). Even as you walk through Concordia’s campus you can quickly see the connections of the Bible, Christian teachings, and equity on a wall with the following verse, “May the nations be glad and sing for joy, for you rule the peoples with equity and guide the nations of the earth. May the people praise you, God; may all the people praise you (Psalms 67:4:5).

Lessons of parables

The Parable of the Talents (Matthew 25:14-30) provides several lessons and points to the need to understand Equity Leadership. Above all, we should use the talents that God has blessed us with, we should grow in the Lord, and even God’s judgment is on an individual basis. We are born with different skills, and each individual has different God-given abilities.

Understanding the Parable of the Talents and Equity Leadership can provide a framework to help unleash the talents of each employee. Rev. Dr. Jamison Hardy has said that “Jesus’s death and resurrection is payment for the sin of the whole world. Even though we all sin differently, Christ has given equity in forgiveness through death and resurrection. The one, sinless man paid for the sins of the entire world.” In addition, God also shows us that in the final hours, he will judge with equity (Psalm 75:1-7)

As is often the case, we seek God’s guidance when we look to understand the world. His example of equitable leadership is prime, showing leaders throughout the world that every person is created uniquely. Further, Rev. Dr. Jamison mentioned, “God provides us proof that equity does not come in the form of equality. Each of us is born with different gifts to use in the Kingdom of God”. Leaders can use the framework of Equity Leadership to navigate how to support followers as human beings and encourage them to foster their God-given talents in the workplace.

Earning a doctoral degree can help you improve your skills

Concordia University Wisconsin’s DBA program includes a concentration in Organizational Performance and Change (OPC) that helps to cultivate expertise in developing highly competent and effective leaders. Our students in the DBA program are current and aspiring leaders who help to create and lead organizational strategies. The OPC concentration emphasizes studying strategies that genuinely improve performance and align with organizational strategies and outcomes. As a result, the program will help students become equitable leaders.

5 best practices for Human Resource Development leaders

As a leader, it’s essential to have the knowledge and skills to train and develop your employees. By studying human resource development (HRD), you can learn how to improve the performance of your team or organization. But, what is HRD exactly? Human resource development utilizes organizational development and personal training to improve employee and organizational performance (Hurtienne et al., 2017).

What do HRD leaders do?

Human resource development professionals will look for ways to unleash human expertise and potential (Swanson & Holton, 2009). For HRD to stay relevant and critical, the core foundations of HRD should be discussed and debated, and theories verified for accuracy through theory development (Hurtienne et al., 2017, p. 17).

By leading through the lens of HRD, leaders understand that if the organization is to improve, then they need to identify the unique differences between their employees and cope with demographic forces (Alshuwairekh, 2016). In fact, organizations should look for ways to understand employee factors that can lead to increased employee engagement (Hurtienne et al., 2021). Senge recommends that organizations find ways to connect with their workforce by tapping into the sense of commitment and ability of each employee to learn and grow.

Why is HRD important?

Successful organizations must find ways to increase employee engagement, performance, and retention. “Human potential and expertise are, and continue to be, a vital component to developing and implementing effective Human Resource Development principles” (Hurtienne et al., 2017, p. 3). Many HRD interventions and methods are acceptable, and not one is right for all situations due to individual experiences, cultures, and beliefs that play a vital role in developing a strategy for success. (Hurtienne et al., 2017).

But what is universal is that leaders need to meet employees where they are and support them in continuing to grow and learn. Applying these practices will improve training, career, and organizational development (Shalleh, 2012).

5 best practices for HRD

HRD professionals should focus their time on acceptance, community development, education, collaboration, and leadership (Hurtienne et al., 2021). Through a pragmatic process, HRD can stay relevant and meet the real needs of organizations and employees (Koranic & Shindell, 2014). Here are some best practices for an HRD leader:

  • Meet with employees often: In order to develop employees successfully, it’s important to form a relationship. Whether it’s individually or in small groups, meeting regularly with your employees is essential.
  • Don’t overload with information: When training employees, it’s important not to give too much information all at once. Split the information into manageable amounts. As a result, employees can immediately practice and use it in their own work. Then, at the next training, they can discuss the implementation.
  • Ask for feedback: Request frequent feedback about the training from employees, therefore, you can continue to improve it.
  • Learn more about learning styles: Remember that everyone learns differently. Provide different ways of digesting information. This can be information that is visual, auditory, kinesthetic, or through reading. You can also approach training in a multi-style approach that accommodates all learning types.
  • Use positive reinforcement: Make sure to give employees positive feedback for the skills they are developing. Employees will feel confident and motivated to further develop their skills while getting positive reinforcement.

Becoming a human resource development leader

You can learn to become an HRD professional at Concordia University Wisconsin/Ann Arbor through the Doctor of Business Administration (DBA). Our organizational performance and change concentration is your pathway to studying HRD. While in the program, our expert faculty will help shape and guide you on your own journey, learning how to improve employee and organizational success.

Reference

Alshuwairekh, K. (2016, October). Exploring the relationship between demographic variables on resistance to change: An empirical study for private sectors in Saudi Arabia. IOSR Journal of Business Management, 18(10), 41-54. https://doi.org/10.9790/487X-1810034154

Hurtienne, M., Hurtienne, L., & Kempen, M. (2021). Employee engagement: Emerging insight of the millennial manufacturing workforce. Human Resource Development Quarterly. DOI: 10.1002/hrdq.21453

Hurtienne, M, Ljubenko, B., & Hurtienne, L. (2017). Theoretical foundations of human resource development: Conceptual visual expansion. Peer-reviewed paper presented at the Academy of  Human Resource Development Conference – 2017, San Antonio, TX, USA

Koranic, M. B., & Shindell, T.J. (2014). Future direction of HRD. In N. E., Chalofsky, T. S. Rocco, & M. L. Morris (Eds.), Handbook of Human Resource Development (pp. 688– 708). Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Salleh, K. M. (2012). Human resource development practitioners’ perspectives on competencies:

An application of American society for training and development (ASTD) workplace learning and performance (WLP) competency model in Malaysi (Doctoral dissertation). Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO.

Want to engage your employees? Start by understanding engagement first.

Engage your employees by learning what engagement is, then seeking understanding.

As professionals, we can read a lot of books. We stream videos, complete formal human resource training, and attend conferences (like the upcoming SHRM conference) to learn more about organizational performance. As a result, we are surrounded by many organizational concepts that can be deployed in our organization to improve performance.

But how do you know if the organizational performance concept is applicable to your situation?

It’s important to see that if you implement any organizational performance concept improperly, it can hurt your culture and your organizational performance. Many change processes fail due to a lack of understanding of the concept being deployed. Sometimes, it’s the right concept, but it’s used improperly. Many of you have studied change and how to evoke change within our workforce ethically. Sometimes, we need to remember the importance of rolling out an organizational improvement process the right way. If we do it incorrectly, it could be seen as negligence or even delict of duty.

Misunderstanding employee engagement

Recently, I had the opportunity to hear about an incident related to employee engagement. An organization discussed the current level of employee engagement with the employees directly. The organization asked for the employees to do better and to help increase the engagement scores. (The current scores showed that the workforce was only 50% engaged.)

In addition, some teams were asked to reach a goal where the entire team was engaged. Although the intent was positive, there seemed to be a lack of understanding of what employee engagement really was. This put the stress of improving employee engagement on the employees, which created a tense environment.

Please take the time to understand the concept you would like to deploy. Commit to understanding how the rollout can impact the outcome.

In the concept of employee engagement, it’s the amount in which employees are willing to invest in the success of the organization “the amount in which employees are willing to invest in the success of the organization” (Hurtienne and Hurtienne, 2001).

Often employee engagement is more of an outcome of leadership and organizational culture. Yes, employees can choose to be more engaged, but they will not unless there is a reason to become more engaged.

Maybe the question should have looked different.

“What can the organization do to help improve employee engagement?” Also, although it would be great to have 100% of our workforce engaged, we also know that the average workforce in the United States is only 30% fully-engaged (Carnegie, 2018). It’s okay to set stretch goals and continue to work for improvement, but make sure it is done in a way that is achievable.

Learn engagement concepts, then engage

When it comes to organizational improvement concepts:

  • Take the time to ensure that the concept is grounded in research.
  • Read case studies on how the concept was utilized in business.
  • Determine the strengths and weaknesses of the concept. Become an expert with eyes wide open.
  • Review to see if the concept is applicable to your organization and that the concept is appropriate for the situation.
  • Explain the concept to the entire workforce.
  • Create a plan to monitor the implementation and ongoing operation of the concept.